My research is in low-dimensional topology, where I study mapping class groups of infinite-type surfaces, and Teichmüller theory of finite-type ones. To study mapping class groups, I build combinatorial graphs, and examine the action of mapping class groups on them. I study Teichmüller space, the space of all hyperbolic metrics on the surface, by looking at geodesics in the Thurston metric.
For more details, see my research statement (updated spring 2023)
For videos, links, and abstracts, see below.
Current projects:
What does the boundary of the grand arc graph look like? Is it connected? Can it be described as a space of laminations as in [Bav-Wal] (work in progress joint with Carolyn Abbott and Arya Vadnere).
Chaitanya Tappu constructed a Teichmuller space for infinite-type surfaces. Is this Teichmuller space metrizable? In general, we think it's not, and we are working on writing up a proof.
Are any big mapping class groups delta-hyperbolic when equipped with a CB-generating set as in [Man-Raf]? In a pretty awesome paper by Anschel Schaffer-Coehn, he proves that the plane minus a Cantor set is. What other surfaces have hyperbolic MCG? I tried working on this with Anschel and Yvon Verberne, but we got stuck on a technical lemma. Still, once that lemma is sorted out, we can probably reach a complete classification.
As a converse to the above, some big MCGs have infinite coarse rank. What about surfaces with no essential shifts? I'm working on this with Yulan Qing and Kasra Rafi. I think this will be a very nice paper.
Some things that have been on my mind:
Is there a clean way to define residual-CB (coarsely-bounded) for groups? If so, are big mapping class groups residually-CB?
Given an essential shift, the boundary of its support defines two grand arcs. If we are to believe that essential shifts are like Dehn twists, and if we are to believe that the grand arc graph is like the curve graph, then a Thurston-type construction of pseudo-Anosov big mapping classes should be possible. That is, if two essential shifts have supports that are far away in the grand arc graph, does a commutator of their powers act loxodromically on the grand arc graph? Is this commutator pseudo-Anosov in another way? [Abb-Pat-Vla] construct loxodromics on arc graphs using a shift and a compactly-supported pseudo-Anosov, but can this construction be generalized to multiple shifts?
Projects that I think are good for students to think about
Are there any mapping classes that act parabolically on the grand arc graph (or any other related graph, for that matter)?
(HARD) Does there exist a heierarchical structure on big mapping class groups? I tried thinking about this for a while, but I couldn't make the finite nesting condition work. Perhaps leveraging the grand arc graph could help somehow?
Do big mapping class groups with a CB generating set have the Morse property?
Is there a version of the fine curve graph but for grand arcs? How does this graph relate to the full homeomorphism group of a surface?
Assaf Bar-Natan, Ken'Ichi Ohshika, Athanase Papadopoulos, Convex structures of the unit tangent spheres in Teichmüller space, preprint
Assaf Bar-Batan, Yvon Verberne, The grand arc graph, Mathematische Zeitschrift volume 305, Article number: 20 (2023)
Assaf Bar-Natan, Advay Goel, Brendan Halstead, Paul Hamrick, Sumedh Shenoy, Rishi Verma, Big Flip Graphs and their Automorphism Groups (2023), Glasnik Matematicki, Vol. 58, No. 1 (2023), 125-134
Assaf Bar-Natan, Elle Najt & Zachary Schutzman, The gerrymandering jumble: map projections permute districts’ compactness scores, Cartography and Geographic Information Science vol. 47, no. 4, pp 321–335
Assaf Bar-Natan, Moon Duchin, Robert Kropholler, Conjugation curvature for Cayley graphs (2020), Journal of Topology and Analysis Vol. 14, No. 02, pp. 439-459 (2022)
Assaf Bar-Natan, Arcs on Punctured Disks Intersecting at Most Twice with Endpoints on the Boundary, Groups, Geometry, and Dynamics Volume 14, Issue 4, 2020, pp. 1309–1332
The Thurston metric on Teichmüller space, first introduced by W.P. Thurston is an asymmetric metric on Teichmüller space. This metric is geodesic, but geodesics are far from unique. In this thesis, we show that in the once-punctured torus, and in the four-times punctured sphere, geodesics stay a uniformly-bounded distance from each other. In other words, we show that the width of the geodesic envelope, E(X,Y) between any pair of points X,Y ∈ T(S) (where S is the once-punctured torus of the four-times punctured sphere) is bounded uniformly. To do this, we first identify extremal geodesics in Env(X,Y), and show that these correspond to stretch vectors, proving a conjecture of Y. Huang, K. Ohshika, and A. Papadopoulos,. We then compute Fenchel-Nielsen twisting along these paths, and use these computations, along with estimates on earthquake path lengths, to prove the main theorem.
In this article, we construct a new simplicial complex for infinite-type surfaces, which we call the grand arc graph. We show that if the end space of a surface has at least three different self-similar equivalence classes of maximal ends, then the grand arc graph is infinite-diameter and δ-hyperbolic. We also show that the mapping class group acts on the grand arc graph by isometries and that the action is quasi-continuous, which is a coarse relaxation of a continuous action. When the surface has stable maximal ends, we also show that this action has finitely many orbits.
A. Bar-Natan, A. Goel, B. Halstead, P. Hamrick, S. Shenoy, R. Verma
In this paper, we study the relationship between the mapping class group of an infinite-type surface and the simultaneous flip graph, a variant of the flip graph for infinite-type surfaces defined by Fossas and Parlier. We show that the extended mapping class group is isomorphic to a proper subgroup of the automorphism group of the flip graph, unlike in the finite-type case. This shows that Ivanov's metaconjecture, which states that any "sufficiently rich" object associated to a finite-type surface has the extended mapping class group as its automorphism group, does not extend to simultaneous flip graphs of infinite-type surfaces.
In political redistricting, the compactness of a district is used as a quantitative proxy for its fairness. Several well-established, yet competing, notions of geographic compactness are commonly used to evaluate the shapes of regions, including the Polsby-Popper score, the convex hull score, and the Reock score, and these scores are used to compare two or more districts or plans. In this paper, we prove mathematically that any map projection from the sphere to the plane reverses the ordering of the scores of some pair of regions for all three of these scores. We evaluate these results empirically on United States congressional districts and demonstrate that this order-reversal does occur in practice with respect to commonly-used projections. Furthermore, the Reock score ordering in particular appears to be quite sensitive to the choice of map projection.
We introduce a notion of Ricci curvature for Cayley graphs that can be thought of as "medium-scale" because it is neither infinitesimal nor asymptotic, but based on a chosen finite radius parameter. We argue that it gives the foundation for a definition of Ricci curvature well adapted to geometric group theory, beginning by observing that the sign can easily be characterized in terms of conjugation in the group. With this conjugation curvature κ, abelian groups are identically flat, and in the other direction we show that κ≡0 implies the group is virtually abelian. Beyond that, κ captures known curvature phenomena in right-angled Artin groups (including free groups) and nilpotent groups, and has a strong relationship to other group-theoretic notions like growth rate and dead ends. We study dependence on generators and behavior under embeddings, and close with directions for further development and study.
Let Dn be the n-punctured disk. We prove that a family of essential simple arcs starting and ending at the boundary and pairwise intersecting at most twice is of size at most n+1 choose 3. On the way, we also show that any nontrivial square complex homeomorphic to a disk whose hyperplanes are simple arcs intersecting at most twice must have a corner or a spur.